Effect of surfactant type on the dyeability and color resistance of semi-permanent basic hair dye

Fashion and Textiles

International Journal of Interdisciplinary Research

Table 9 Comparison of color difference of bleached hair (BH) by dye type after 10 times of shampooing using three different shampoos (α = 0.05)

Shampoo	Color	Hair-Dye	N	Mean	SE	Duncan	F	p
Ac	L*	BH-CBD	6	3.34	0.23	a	40.245	.000
		BH-NBD	6	2.85	0.32	a
		BH-ABD	6	6.08	0.27	b
	a*	BH-CBD	6	8.53	0.44	b	122.187	.000
		BH-NBD	6	8.55	0.23	b
		BH-ABD	6	0.32	0.55	a
	b*	BH-CBD	6	0.87	0.45	a	23.114	.000
		BH-NBD	6	1.67	0.38	a
		BH-ABD	6	4.86	0.48	b
	ΔE^*_ab	BH-CBD	6	9.26	0.50	b	3.296	.065
		BH-NBD	6	9.22	0.25	b
		BH-ABD	6	7.91	0.48	a
Ne	L*	BH-CBD	6	2.51	0.43	a	29.439	.000
		BH-NBD	6	2.66	0.50	a
		BH-ABD	6	6.43	0.26	b
	a*	BH-CBD	6	8.98	0.35	b	130.770	.000
		BH-NBD	6	10.43	0.56	c
		BH-ABD	6	1.57	0.30	a
	b*	BH-CBD	6	0.86	0.35	a	27.601	.000
		BH-NBD	6	1.54	0.33	a
		BH-ABD	6	5.21	0.57	b
	ΔE^*_ab	BH-CBD	6	9.19	0.41	a	11.069	.001
		BH-NBD	6	11.57	0.24	b
		BH-ABD	6	8.74	0.63	a
Al	L*	BH-CBD	6	3.24	0.30	a	68.724	.000
		BH-NBD	6	2.77	0.35	a
		BH-ABD	6	7.66	0.32	b
	a*	BH-CBD	6	1.00	0.41	b	251.659	.000
		BH-NBD	6	9.34	0.16	b
		BH-ABD	6	0.82	0.28	a
	b*	BH-CBD	6	1.36	0.47	a	54.614	.000
		BH-NBD	6	1.54	0.13	a
		BH-ABD	6	5.98	0.37	b
	ΔE^*_ab	BH-CBD	6	9.37	0.47	a	1.239	.318
		BH-NBD	6	10.24	0.17	a
		BH-ABD	6	9.57	0.51	a

^* The same letter in the Duncan column indicate that the mean of groups are not different at α = 0.05. CBD cationic basic hair dye, NBD nonionic basic hair dye, ABD anionic basic hair dye, Ac acidic shampoo, Ne neutral shampoo, Al alkaline shampoo